When contact changes minds (for real this time) · ↗ www.scunning.com
A fabriated study but a real effect
“When Contact Changes Minds” was a study published in 2014 with a result that seemed almost too good to be true—a single discussion with a gay canvasser (but not a straight one) could durably change voters’ minds on gay marriage (for at least 9 months). The only problem? The grad student behind it had fabricated the data, and the paper was eventually retracted with the support of the senior author.
Economist Scott Cunningham has a fascinating slide deck on the statistical tells that led to the fraudulent research being uncovered.
The real kicker here is that the effect actually did turn out to be sort of real. A subsequent study found that a single conversation could durably change people’s attitudes toward transgender people (at least up to 3 months later). But the most interesting finding from the original paper did not replicate: the effect did not significantly differ between transgender and non-transgender canvassers.
